Poshmark Review: What You Need to Know Before Buying & Selling on Poshmark

Poshmark Review: What You Need to Know Before Buying & Selling on Poshmark


Online shopping is growing by leaps and bounds year after year. Poshmark is one of the online places where people can buy and sell new and used clothes, shoes, accessories, and household goods. Started in 2011, Poshmark has grown to over 40 million users, making it one of the most popular online marketplaces in the US.

I’ve been buying and selling on Poshmark for since 2015. This Poshmark review is based on my experience so that you have you need to know before buying and selling on the platform.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. This means that I may receive compensation when you click on a product link or purchase an item linked on this site. Click here for details.

***If you don’t have a Poshmark account, you can receive a free $5 bonus when you sign up with my code SFGIRL2015. ***

Related posts:


Background

Poshmark started as a small company focused on selling primarily second-hand women’s clothing, shoes, and accessories. Over the years, it has expanded to allow men’s and children’s items.

It’s grown its boutique market for items sold directly from wholesale to customer. In 2019, Poshmark expanded into the home goods market and launched into the Canadian market.

Poshmark has made clear that it intends to expand its offerings and expand internationally. If that happens, you’ll find more and more new buyers and sellers on the platform.

That means buyers will find more goods to meet their wants and needs. For sellers, that means greater opportunity to reach more customers and make more sales.

 
 
Poshmark homepage & feed

Poshmark homepage & feed

 

Buying on Poshmark

The best things about buying on Poshmark are

  • Saving money! You can buy items at lower than retail and sometimes even lower than any other place on the internet. You’ll save lots of money if you shop smartly.


  • Replacing worn items – I’ve been able to find replacements for items that I’ve loved and worn out. These items are no longer sold in stores because they’re seasons old. Sometimes they’re being sold in good condition or even new on Poshmark.


  • Finding rare or unique items. The more time you spend on Poshmark, you’ll find that people have some unique listings like one-of-a-kind jewelry, vintage dresses, and antique dishware.


Benefits as a Buyer

  • Ability to negotiate prices – Poshmark has a “make an offer” button that lets shoppers open negotiations with sellers. Sellers can accept or counter offers. This goes back and forth until an offer is declined or the item is sold.

    Sometimes you really want an item but just don’t want to or can’t afford to pay the listed price. Go ahead and start a negotiation. Most sellers expect that this will happen and price their items accordingly. They’re often willing to discount items in order to make a sale.



  • Discounted USPS Priority shipping – Shipping is currently $6.79 at the time of this review. You’ll hear a lot of people complain that shipping is too expensive. It’s already $5+ to ship items almost 1 lb using regular USPS first-class package service.

    You’re getting a deal shipping anything from 1-5 pounds, the max weight the Poshmark label covers. You wouldn’t find that good a deal on other sites like eBay and Mercari, where shipping has gotten so expensive.

    Sometimes Poshmark holds specials where shipping is discounted even further to $4.99 or $3.99. The additional cost is covered by Poshmark.

    The other benefit a set shipping cost is that you know exactly how much you’re going to pay for shipping. Shipping is tracked, and you can expect your package within 3 days of shipment.



  • Poshmark is fast and easy to use. It’s fairly easy to look for what you want on the platform. You can search by keyword and filter by a number of options like color, price, and item condition.

    The most time-consuming part for buyers may be browsing all the available listings. But once you find what you want, it’s quick and easy to check out. You pay using a credit card or PayPal at the time of purchase.

    On eBay, you might wait to see if you’ve won a multi-day auction, consider payment types and shipping fees, then have to remember to pay within the seller’s desired timeframe. Poshmark is more simplified.



  • Availability of on-trend brands and styles – Poshmark is full of fashion-forward items. Do you like Lululemon, For Love and Lemons, Nike, and Kate Spade? You’ll find lots of all of them on Poshmark. It’s one of the best places to look for popular bands and the latest styles below retail prices.



  • Buyer protection – Poshmark protects buyers in the case of receiving an item not as described, receiving a counterfeit item, not receiving the item at all due to having been lost in the mail or the item not having been shipped.

    Buyers also have 3 days upon receiving the item to check it and accept it. You can open a case within those three days if you feel there’s anything wrong with the item and would like to obtain a refund.



  • Authentication of luxury goods. Poshmark offers free authentication of items purchased for $500 or more. Items are sent to PM headquarters, where their team checks items for authenticity. It’s an added layer of protection against monetary loss and receiving counterfeit goods.



  • You don’t have to be social to buy. Poshmark is set up as a social platform. You’ll hear a lot of people talk about how much time and work they put into the platform because of its social focus, meaning sharing listings, attending virtual parties, and so forth. That’s only necessary for seller success.

    As a buyer, you don’t need to do more than search for what you want, maybe negotiate the price, and purchase the item. Don’t buy into the idea that you have to be social to get the most out of Poshmark.



Negatives as a Buyer

  • Varying quality and descriptions of items. When you buy second-hand items online, you’re taking a gamble. You can’t touch the item or see it in person before purchasing, so you rely on the seller’s description and pictures.

    People have different ideas about items’ conditions. One person might consider an item with fading and pilling to still be in good condition while another would find it unacceptable to even wear.

    When you rely on someone else’s description for millions of second-hand items, there are bound to be differences in opinion and inconsistencies between descriptions and reality, both of which lead to unhappy buyers.



  • Sales are final. All sales are final unless an item wasn’t received as described. You get a 3-hour window after purchasing to cancel an order. If the item doesn’t fit or you have buyer’s remorse after that window, you’re stuck with the item.

    Consider that most brick-and-mortar stores and online retailers offer refunds. It’s not hard to buy something when you know you can return it. It’s harder to pull the trigger to shop a final sale. You have to know you’ll like the item and you’d better be getting a good deal to make up for the risk.



  • Counterfeit goods. The internet is filled with counterfeit goods for sale. It’s not only on Poshmark. Inauthentic goods can be found on every second-hand sales platform. Unfortunately, Poshmark is not the fastest or most attentive to getting those items removed.

    That means buyers could be duped into buying counterfeit goods, particularly people who are unknowledgeable about these things. It’s annoying to go through the hassle of opening a case for a counterfeit good and potentially losing the case and your money.

    Caveat emptor. If you’re looking to purchase a high-end item, do your research to recognize if it’s counterfeited. Learn how to identify an authentic version of the item before you make a purchase.



  • Lots of dead closets. One of the most challenging things about buying is the presence of so many dead closets. These are closets set up by PM users and then abandoned due to time, inactivity, loss of interest in the app, and other reasons.

    You ask a seller a question about an item and never hear back from him or her. You buy an item and it never ships. That’s because these sellers are no longer active on Poshmark, but their closets and items are still up for sale. Poshmark doesn’t differentiate between active and dead closets.


  • Taxes. Poshmark started collecting taxes on purchases as they are required to by law. This is helpful for sellers, but it’s just another added cost to buyers. You might find yourself wanting a $15 shirt and find the total cost close to $25 after taxes and shipping are included. You might consider that too much to pay for a used item.


  • Slow shipping. Although Poshmark recommends sellers ship within 2 days of a purchase, sellers have up to 7 days to ship an item before the sale can be canceled. Some sellers take a long time to ship items and there’s not much you can do about it as a buyer.

    I always try to ship on the same day or the next day, so know that there are many attentive sellers out there too.


  • Customer service is through email. Email is the only method of customer service. There’s no phone service yet, although I hope there will be one day because it can be a pain to wait 24-48 hours for a response to your email.



Tips for a Better Buyer Experience

Now here are some tips to follow so that you have a positive buying experience on Poshmark.

  • Follow your favorite brands. Follow your favorite brands to keep up with the newest listings on the site. The latest listings will show up in your home feed. You can further sort by “just in”, price, recently priced dropped, or your preset sizes.
    If you’re looking for a specific item in a particular size, you may have to be patient and check frequently to see if the item comes up for sale.


  • Like your favorite items. Like an item to be notified when the seller drops the price of it. The is sometimes offered in conjunction with a discounted shipping so you get even more of a deal. Check that your notifications are on either by text or email to be notified right away.


  • Bundle your favorite items. Add your favorite items to bundles to take advantage of bundle discounts, ability to negotiate price semi-privately, and one shipping fee for multiple items. Most sellers are willing to give you a deal on the price when you’re buying more than one item from them.


  • Ask questions! Go ahead and ask questions. Ask about the condition. Ask for measurements. Ask if the item is still available.

    If the seller doesn’t have all sides of an item showing, go ahead and ask for more pictures. Some sellers will oblige and some won’t. A seller who takes their business seriously will answer your question quickly, and those are the people you want to shop from.


  • Ensure you’re comfortable with the price you’re paying. Find the item you want at a price you’re comfortable paying. Poshmark prices tend to be higher than those found on other sites. Add taxes and shipping fees to the price and you could end up paying much more than you expected.

    If you have a price you’re comfortable with in mind, you’re much less likely to have buyer’s remorse or an unsatisfactory shopping experience.


  • Look at the seller’s feedback. Positive feedback is shown publicly; negative feedback is not. You can be more confident in your purchase if the seller has lots of positive feedback. Other indicators of a reliable seller:

    • How long they’ve been on the platform – You can see when a person joined Poshmark. Generally the longer the person has been on the platform, the more experienced he or she is with it.

    • How many listings are in their closet – Sellers with large closets (several hundred items to thousands of items) are probably selling as a business.

    • Their ship time – This isn’t shown publicly unless they provide a screenshot in their profile or state in their profile description. Many sellers share that they are fast shippers (<2 days).

    • Their response time – When you ask a question, does the seller respond within a reasonable amount of time? That’s an indication of someone who’s active on the platform.

    • Poshmark Ambassador status – Some sellers share that they’re a Poshmark Ambassador in their closet name or listings. They’ve met certain criteria for sales, shares, ship time, and more to achieve that designation.



  • Pass on an item if you’re questionable about it. Poshmark’s policy is all sales final, so I recommend buying an item only if you’re sure that you want it or are willing to take the risk and have a backup plan for the item if it doesn’t work out. Some people reposh (relist) the item for sale if it doesn’t fit. Others may give the item away to someone who would like it.


  • Read Poshmark’s guidelines before you purchase. Take the time to read up on Poshmark’s guidelines because every platform works differently. This will help to avoid many of the misunderstandings and issues I see come up between buyers and sellers. The biggest issues I see around this are

    • Requests for returns due to fit or changing one’s mind. Sales are final.

    • Requests for refunds after the 3-day acceptance window. Be sure to inspect the items you receive and try them on before the three days are up. On the fourth day, payment is released to the seller and you cannot open a case for the item anymore.

    • Taking transactions off of Poshmark. This is attractive for a lower price and cheaper shipping but removes any buyer protection. Poshmark doesn’t allow it, and it can get you banned from the platform.

 
Creating a new listing on Poshmark

Creating a new listing on Poshmark

 

Selling on Poshmark

The best thing about selling on Poshmark is

  • Making money! This is probably the number one reason why people sell on the platform. Whether they’re just listing a few items to clean out their home closets or they are full-time sellers with thousands of listings, both have the same goal of making a profit from their sales. Poshmark helps them do that.


Benefits for a seller

  • No listing fees. You can list as many items as you want for free. Yay! There’s no limit to the amount of money you can make on Poshmark because it’s free to list and the sky’s the limit.



  • Quick and easy listings. Poshmark was originally created as an app to be used on a cell phone. That’s why it’s easy to snap a few pictures, write a description, click a few buttons for additional details, and price the item. It’s different from a site like eBay that has a difficult user interface and wants you to select detail after detail per item.



  • Many features to promote sales. Poshmark wants you to make sales. That’s how they make their money too. To that end, they offer features for sellers to use to make sales such as offering bundle discounts and making it easy to negotiate prices. Poshmark itself holds events such as Closet Clear Out and covers the cost of discounted shipping to entice buyers.



  • Straight-forward shipping process and fees. Shipping is all done through USPS Priority mail. When you make a sale, the shipping label is sent to you or you can download it. You just attach it to your package and it’s ready to go.

    No need to calculate postage (under 5 lb). Even shipping boxes can be obtained free through USPS so you can spend very little on packaging supplies.



  • No returns. This is great for the seller because once an item is accepted by the buyer or after the 3-day acceptance window passes, the sales proceeds are transferred to you and it’s yours to do with what you’d like. You don’t have to worry about being asked for a return or refund after that.



  • Poshmark Ambassador status. I like that Poshmark offers this designation to let people know you’re a reliable seller. After you’ve met certain criteria for buying and selling, you can become a Poshmark Ambassador. People feel more confident buying from you knowing that you are one.



  • Taxes. Poshmark collects tax on sales (as required by law) and remits them to states on behalf of sellers. As a seller, you don’t have to collect tax yourself and then send it to the state each year. That would be a huge headache. Poshmark does all of that for you. How amazing is that?



Negatives for a seller

  • High commission. The biggest downside of selling on Poshmark is the commission. It’s a flat commission rate of $2.95 for anything under $15. It’s 20% for items $15 and above.

    That really cuts into profits, particularly for lower priced items. I suggest avoiding selling low priced items <$10 if possible.



  • Time-consuming to maximize Poshmark’s potential. Poshmark is a social platform. Most sellers have to be active on the platform to see more sales. It’s time-consuming to share other people’s listings, share your own listings, attend Poshmark virtual parties, negotiate with buyers, and frequently list and relist items. Poshmark can take all your time if you let it.



  • Shipping costs for items under 1 lb. As mentioned above, shipping is a great deal for items 1 lb and above. Items under 1 lb could be shipped cheaper through first-class commercial service if Poshmark had that option. This makes shipping a considerable expense for small lightweight items.



  • Competitive pricing. First off people come to Poshmark looking for a good deal. They want the lowest prices they can get. Then there’s the fact that Poshmark has millions of sellers.

    The main way to be competitive on the platform is through pricing. If you’re selling something that a lot of other people are selling, then you don’t have much flexibility on price if you want to make a sale. You have to match other sellers’ prices, which could be low and eat into your profit.



  • Buyer scams. You may be unfortunate to run into someone who tries to scam you out of your item. There are a few main ways they try to do this on Poshmark.

    Sometimes it’s saying that they received a different item than they ordered or it was more damaged than described. Sometimes they’ll say they received an empty box. It’s frustrating, but it’s a part of every business that sells online.

    Scammers are on every site, not just Poshmark. And scammers are on both sides of the transaction. Sellers can be scammers too. It’s important to be aware of the issue though if you’re planning to sell online.



Tips for a Better Seller Experience

  • Know Poshmark’s guidelines. Read up on what’s allowed and not allowed on the platform as well as what’s expected of sellers (e.g., shipping within two days of a sale). It’s good to know that Poshmark handles all customer service through email so you may have to wait 24-48 hours for a response, even on a pressing issue.



  • Keep all transactions professional and on the platform. If you’re selling as a business and want to continue to long-term success, keep all communication professional. Ignore any negative comments and let open cases roll off your back. Focus on the positives you bring to your business and the happy customers that you have.



  • Join in the social aspects of the platform. Poshmark is built around being social, which is necessary for most sellers to see the success they want. Share your items several times a day. Grow your follower list. Share other people’s items. Join in virtual parties held throughout the day. The payoff is more sales, which happens when you’re more active on Poshmark.



  • Check the buyer’s profile. You can sometimes get a better idea of a buyer by looking at their closet and profile. If you see they have a lot of listings or good feedback, then they’re more likely to know how Poshmark works and be a reliable buyer. That can calm nerves when selling high-end items worth hundreds of dollars.



  • Protect yourself when selling high-end items. It’s okay to take additional pictures of items, record yourself packaging items, and add copies of original receipts. I don’t do this myself because the items I sell are <$100, but it’s good to do if you’re concerned about attempts at scams or claims of inauthenticity.



  • Enjoy what you do. If you like the Poshmark platform and you like being a seller, you’re much more likely to enjoy the whole experience of selling on Poshmark. I’ve passed on other money-making side hustles because I knew I wouldn’t like them, even if they were profitable. You’ll have a better experience selling if you already find it enjoyable.



Wrap Up

I’ve been active on Poshmark as a buyer and a seller for several years. In that time, I’ve read and heard many Poshmark reviews, complaints, and praises. I’ve read more negative comments about the platform than I hoped there would be.

That doesn’t mean that most people’s experiences on the platform are bad. Remember that there are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Poshmark buyers and sellers who have had great experiences on the platform.

They don’t voice their satisfaction simply because they are happy with their experience and move on with their lives. That’s how Poshmark continues to do well growing with no end in sight.

I’ve tried my best to provide a fair review of Poshmark from both a buyer’s and a seller’s perspectives. As you can see, there are pros and cons to both the buying and selling sides.

I still think Poshmark is one of the easiest places to buy and sell items online. And using the tips above, you’ll be more assured of a great experience.

Want to try it out for yourself? Sign up and start using Poshmark today!



By the way, I created this handout on 200+ top-selling brands to know to help you find the best thrifted items so you can make more sales. Click on the button below to grab your copy!

 
poshmark review 3.jpg
poshmark review 2.jpg
 
 
poshmark review 1.jpg